Certificate of Independent Legal Advice for your Binding Financial Agreement – The role of your Lawyer

A key requirement for a Binding Financial Agreement (also known as a “BFA”) to be enforceable is that each party must receive independent legal advice, which is formally confirmed through a signed statement (“Certificate of Independence”). But what does this mean in practice, and what exactly does a Lawyer do in this process?

In Family Law matters, BFA’s are an important tool for couples who want to set out how their property, finances, and spousal maintenance will be handled if their relationship or marriage breaks down, or once a relationship or marriage has ended.

You can read more about the differences between these types of Agreements and the strict legal requirements here.

In family law matters, BFA’s are an important tool for couples who want to set out how their property, finances, and spousal maintenance will be handled if their relationship or marriage breaks down, or once a relationship or marriage has ended. You can read more about the differences between these types of Agreements and the strict legal requirements here: https://delaneyrobertsfamilylawyers.com.au/understanding-the-difference-between-financial-agreements-bfas-termination-agreements-and-prenuptial-agreements/

What is a Certificate of Independence?

A Certificate of Independence is a formal statement, usually annexed to the BFA, in which a Lawyer certifies that they have provided independent legal advice to their client regarding the effect of the agreement on the client’s rights, and the advantages and disadvantages of entering into the agreement.

This certificate is a statutory safeguard designed to ensure that parties enter into BFAs with full knowledge and understanding of their legal position.

We offer a Fixed Fee for a Certificate of Independent Legal Advice for a Binding Financial Agreement after separation.

The Lawyer’s Role

A lawyer’s role in obtaining a Certificate of Independence is essential and involves several important steps.

Here’s what it looks like in practice:

1. Providing Independent Legal Advice

The lawyer must give advice explaining:

  • How the BFA affects their client’s rights.
  • The advantages and disadvantages to the party of entering into the BFA at the time of the agreement.

The advice should be tailored to the client’s situation and delivered in plain language so they can fully understand what they are signing.

In order to provide this advice the Lawyer needs to review the Binding Financial Agreement and any supporting documentation used to draft the BFA including financial disclosure.

2. Ensuring True Independence

Each party must have their own lawyer.

No lawyer can act for both parties, and any potential conflicts of interest must be avoided.

Having an independent lawyer also ensures there is no pressure or influence affecting the client and is therefore crucial for the certificate to be valid.

3. Reviewing and Explaining the Agreement

Lawyers carefully go through the agreement, explaining key points for example how assets and property are divided, spousal maintenance provisions, future claims, and how the agreement could be changed or ended.

They also highlight any risks or unfair terms, so the client is fully aware of what they are agreeing to.

4. Certifying the Advice

Once the client has received and understood the advice, the lawyer signs the Certificate of Independence.

This certificate is attached to the BFA, and a copy is given to the other party or their lawyer, confirming that proper independent advice has been provided.

5.Assessing Capacity and Voluntariness

Finally, the lawyer must be satisfied that the client fully understands the agreement and is signing it voluntarily.

If there are concerns about duress, undue influence, or the client’s ability to understand the terms, the lawyer must address these issues or may decide not to provide the certificate.

What happens if there isn’t a Certificate of Independence, or it isn’t signed properly?

A Financial Agreement can be set aside if either party did not receive independent legal advice. This means that even if both parties signed the agreement, it may not be enforceable if the Certificate of Independence is not signed by a Lawyer.

This is why the Certificate of Independence is so important. It provides written confirmation that the lawyer has explained the effect of the agreement, discussed its advantages and disadvantages, and that the advice was given independently.

Ultimately, getting proper legal advice before signing a BFA is more than just a legal requirement. It is an essential step to make sure the agreement is valid and enforceable.

Examples of previous cases regarding Independent Legal Advice for a Binding Financial Agreement

Sullivan & Sullivan [2011] FamCA 752

The parties signed what they believed was a Binding Financial Agreement made before marriage under section 90B of the Family Law Act 1975. However, the husband’s solicitor did not sign his certificate of independent legal advice until after the marriage took place.

This meant the agreement should have been made under section 90C (during marriage), not 90B. Despite both parties’ obtaining independent legal advice and their solicitors signing certificates, the certificates referenced the wrong section of the Act.

The Court found that because the agreement and certificates did not comply with the correct legislative section, there was no valid financial agreement. The existence of solicitor certificates on their own did not “save” the agreement as the technical compliance with the Act was still essential.

Renard & Geach [2013]

The Court said:

It is difficult to see how that role could be fulfilled in even a 50 minute interview, as it would require detailed instructions being taken as to the assets and liabilities of the marriage, the husband’s current position, and the history of the relationship before even looking at the agreement.

I therefore consider that I do not need to make a finding on the exact length of time Mr Young spent alone with the husband … as even on Mr Young’s evidence, it was not in my view long enough to take comprehensive instructions and give detailed and comprehensive advice about the agreement.

In summary, advice must be given in accordance with the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) to ensure a BFA is binding and enforceable. The role of a lawyer is not to simply “give a certificate”.

How We Help

Past cases demonstrate how even a small technical mistake, such as referring to the wrong section of the Family Law Act, can make a Financial Agreement invalid, and that getting independent legal advice is not simply about having a lawyer sign a certificate.

It is about making sure the advice, the process, and the documents all fully comply with the law.

Our specialist Family Lawyers understand both the legal requirements and how each part of a Financial Agreement affects you in practice.

We make sure the Certificate of Independence is prepared properly, identify any risks, and help you avoid technical issues that could cause problems down the track. To get started we offer a Fixed Fee.

Specialist Family Lawyers for Sydney and Newcastle

Make a Smart Start

  • 90-minute appointment with a Specialist Family Lawyer
  • Get all your questions answered and understand applicable Family Law processes
  • Comprehensive on-the-spot legal advice tailored to your circumstances
  • Develop a plan to secure your best future
  • $350 Fixed Fee (incl GST)

Book a Smart Start Appointment Online 24/7

Make a Fresh Start. Contact Us Today

The information in this article is not legal advice and is intended to provide commentary and general information only. It should not be relied upon or used as a definitive or complete statement of the relevant law. You should obtain formal legal advice specific to your particular circumstance. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Author
Senior Associate Solicitor